10- Unjustified justifications!

The Official Website of Grand Ayatollah Makarem Shirazi

صفحه کاربران ویژه - خروج
Sort by
 
11- Oppressedness of Ali (a.s.)9- Punishment of some of Sahaba in age of Prophet (s.a.) or after that time!

1- Followers of complete infallibly and holiness of Sahaba when confront this mass of oppositions, convince themselves with this justification that All of Sahaba were Mujtahid and any of them acted due to his Ijtihad.

Undoubtedly this is a kind of self deception that these brothers use against such clear oppositions.

Is beating a believer Sahaba for just a gentle animadversion and ordering to do good and inhibiting from doing bad according to acts about embezzling bursary until he passed out and missed his prayers, Ijtihad?

Is breaking a rib of a famous Sahaba due to protesting for placing a drunk (Waleed) as a governor of Kufa, a kind of Ijtihad?

And more important from them inaugurating wars which killed tens of thousands of Muslims, just for cupidity and ambition and for acquiring Islamic government, and do all these against Imam of Muslims who beside divine ranks had chosen by majority of people, are all these acts a kind of Ijtihad?

If these and all acts like them are branches of Ijtihad, it is possible to justify all crimes in history with that.

Moreover, were Ijtihad exclusive to Sahaba or at least there were lots of Mujtahids among Islamic society some centuries later and as some thinkers of Ahl -e- Sonnat and all scholars of Shi’aa say today also Ijtihad is available for all wise scholars?

If one of these persons in these days performs acts like those before, are you ready to justify them with Ijtihad?! Surely, no.

2- Sometimes they say that we have duty to keep silence about them. “There are people who passed away, their acts are for themselves and your acts are for yourselves, and you are not in charge of their acts”.1

But the question is that if they did not affect our destiny, this expression might be good, but we want to receive cabbalas of Prophet by them and make them as our patterns, shouldn’t we recognize pure from impure and impartial from debauchee to act to the meaning of holy verse: “When a debauchee brought you news do not accept that without investigation.”2

 

 


1- Baqara Sura, verse 134.
2- Hojorat Sura, verse 6.

 

 

 

11- Oppressedness of Ali (a.s.)9- Punishment of some of Sahaba in age of Prophet (s.a.) or after that time!
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
Lotus
Mitra
Nazanin
Titr
Tahoma